The Masked Singer fans are convinced there is a major twist in store when the identity of Toad in the Hole is revealed. Viewers have flooded the show’s Twitter account to say it is ‘obviously’ a star who has already appeared on the show three times.
Fans are ‘100000% sure’ it is iconic singer Macy Gray performing on the ITV show inside the bizarre costume, mostly due to her distinctive voice and also one clue in particular. Macy has already taken part in the huge guessing game – appearing as Daisy on series one of the UK show back in 2020.
In 2021, Macy competed in season three of the Australian version of The Masked Singer as “Atlantis”. And in 2023, she competed in season ten of The Masked Singer USA as the wild card contestant “Sea Queen”.
Read more Masked Singer fans spot major Kingfisher clue as star ‘outs himself’ on another TV show
Fans are convinced she is back for a fourth time, especially as nutmeg was mentioned during the clues for the character. Macy Gray has a song called My Nutmeg Phantasy.
One fan wrote on X, formerly Twitter: “Sounds like Macy Gray but thought she’d been on before? #maskedsingeruk.” A second said: “If it is Macy Gray & is thus going for the hatrick, having done Australia & the USA versions of “The Masked Singer” does that mean you can do as many countries as you want, unlike Strictly, which I think you can only do one version of #TheMaskedSinger #TheMaskedSingerUK.”
Others flooded the show’s hashtag saying it was definitely Macy inside the costume. One wrote: “Macy Gray had a song called ‘My Nutmeg Phantasy’ – Toad in the Hole is deffo her! #MaskedSingerUK.” Another said: “I thought tracy chapman last week but it sounds too much like macy gray. She also has a song called nutmeg fantasy. Wasnt nutmeg tea a clue? #MaskedSingerUK.”
“Toad in the Hole is definitely Macy Gray #maskedsingeruk #TheMaskedSinger,” a third commented, while a fourth echoes: “Yeah. I’m on then Macy Grey train.”
A fifth wrote: “Macy grey 100000% #maskedsingeruk.” Another fan added: “Toad In The Hole – Macy Gray. Goes without saying.” And a sixth said: “Macy Gray has got to be toad in the hole there’s that distinctive voice! It’s her voice!”